the blow up

[info]frumiousb


Counting My Blessings

An exercise in positivity.


Previous Entry Remember Tell Next Entry
Book 104. Perfect Circle, Sean Stewart
doris lessing
[info]frumiousb
I think I have said this before. Several times before, even. Sean Stewart is a *wonderful* writer. His characters have great sensitivity and depth. His humor is subtle, but effective.

I have not always found his plotting skills were as good as the rest of the package. I thought the first few books I read by him were slight and a little bit easy to forget. Then I read Mockingbird, and it was an astonishing novel. Everything good combined to be something great-- I still really recommend it.

Perfect Circle is not, to my mind, quite as good as Mockingbird, but it is awfully close. Ostensibly about ghosts (at least according to the cover), it is more about a man trying to fix his life in the face of unusual talents and the usual handicaps. There was something about the plot that reminded me oddly of Douglas Coupland's novels. I suspect neither author would appreciate the comparison, but there you go.

When I look back on the book, I find the ending has melted away from my memory. I can discover it back again quickly. Still, there is something a little unfinished about the ending which makes it slightly less strong than Mockingbird. At least for me.

Meet William "Dead" Kennedy and find out for yourself.

I love Mockingbird! It's one of my favourite modern fantasy novels. I thought he carried off narration by a pregnant woman really well -- not something you can say about a lot of male novelists. I think I have Circle around here, too, altho I first got to know his writing through the AI game a while back.

Mockingbird is better, I think. But this is pretty great.


Home